A New Problem Solving Method   Thomas Teepe
                               February 19, 2011
What is my aim?


I present my favourite
hands-on method of problem solving
(… and of thinking in general)
What are the basic ideas?


It's a combination of 2 things:   This combination works
                                  for me much better than
1.notemaking                      each of its 2 components
  - using several clever tricks   on their own.

2.tools
  for problem solving
… with an emphasis on
reflective thinking!              'Reflective ' sounded
                                  academic and boring.
                                  I thought again ;-) -
                                  reflection is central for
                                  solving tough problems.
First:       Second:
             Problem Solving Tools
Notemaking
Why Notemaking?                          Some famous
                                         notemakers:
●   support concentration                Leonardo da Vinci
●   master complex thoughts              Isaac Newton
    ●   break down a problem into        Charles Darwin
        smaller parts                    Ludwig van Beethoven
    ●   collect ideas first              Thomas Edison
        and examine them afterwards      Pablo Picasso
●   combine verbal and visual thinking   Carl Friedrich Gauss
●   see ideas from a distance            Oscar Wilde
●   document thoughts                    Alfred Hitchcock


●   can be adapted in many ways
Basics of
the notemaking process 1


We use a
two-column layout
1.left column for the main material
2.right column for                    For me, the 'reflection
  - reflection,                       column' is simple &
                                      effective support to guide
  - comments,
                                      my thoughts
  - questions
  - etc.
Basics of
the notemaking process 2


I use                                   Some basic ideas come
                                        from mind mapping
several elements in combination
●   keywords
●   hierarchical arrangement of ideas
●   combining words and images
●   colours (sometimes)
                                        I find tables very
●   tables                              powerful - yet somewhat
●   diagrams                            underrated and
                                        underused in mind
                                        mapping
Some remarks on writing materials

Goal:
●   get lots of content on one page   Surprisingly relevant.

●   … and stay legible


This works well for me:
                                      Imho, superior to 0,5 mm
●   mechanical pencil 0,3 mm HB
●   a bound notebook
    blank pages, size A5
●   small handwriting                 even tiny
Here is a
step-by-step example.
Main     start with
                          Reflection
Column   the separation
         line
                          Column
add
headline
arrange ideas
in hierarchies
add diagrams
add tables
add to do items
add checkmarks later
add reflections
Second:                 First was
                        Notemaking
Problem Solving Tools
What is a problem solving tool?
                                   naive but useful
●   everything that may help       defintion
    to solve a problem


Examples
●   brainstorm
●   ask yourself questions
●   ask a colleague
●   search the internet
●   sleep over it
●   reflect:
    ●   improve your ideas
    ●   understand how you think
How to organize problem solving
tools?
●   Step 1:
    Split the problem solving process
    into stages
●   Step 2:
    For each stage,
    collect a number of useful tools


●   Plus:
    Reflection tools
    that help at each stage
Stages of problem solving
- a simple model:

●   understand the problem
●   define reasonable goals
●   develop plans for the goals
●   choose a plan
●   carry out the plan
●   reflect                       reflection is useful
                                  1) in each of the other
                                  stages
                                  2) for a final look back
Here comes
a small collection of tools
for each stage
Understand the problem
●   start with a top-down analysis
●   ask questions
●   collect information about the
    problem
    ●   internet search
    ●   literature
    ●   interview people
●   draw a diagram
Define reasonable goals
●   What is the right thing to do?
●   What would XY do?                XY is a person I take as a
                                     role model in the given
●   state goals clearly              problem situation.
●   describe SMART goals
    ●   S - specific
    ●   M - measurable
    ●   A - attainable
    ●   R - relevant
    ●   T - time bound
Develop plans for these goals
●   start with the goal
    and develop a plan backwards
●   develop a plan top-down:
    start with a general plan and make it
    more specific
●   ask repeatedly
    'How can this be achieved?'
●   exploit solutions from similar or
    analogue problems
●   brainstorm for unusual ideas
Choose a plan
●   check the plans for obstacles,
    gaps...
●   compare plans pairwise
●   list the pros and cons
●   trust your gut feeling
Reflection
                                         In my experience, these
●   So what?                             simple questions are
    What now?                            surprisingly powerful.
●   collect shortcomings and criticism
●   collect obstacles and barriers
●   collect conflicts
●   examine results
I often use only
two simple sets of tools
1.one for the main column:
                                   I write these acronyms on
  PrAnGoPlExCo stands for          top of the columns – each
  Problem Description              time a useful reminder of
  Analysis                         good problem solving
  Goals                            practices.
  Plans                            Constantly adapting
  Execute plan                     these tools to my personal
  Control                          needs is paramount.

2.one for the reflection column:
  QOCS stands for
  Questions
  Obstacles
  Conflicts
  So what?!
How to combine notemaking and
problem solving tools?


Here is an example.
Start with
- separation line
- tool acronym PrAnGoPlExCo
- tool acronym QOCS
add headline
start with tool 'Pr' = Problem Description
use reflection tools
use further tools
from PrAnGoPlExCo
Advantages
For me, the method is...
●   effective:
    notemaking + tools guide my
    thinking through problems
●   efficient:
    no needless fuss -
    simple, quick, cheap and
    easily available
●   flexible:
    can be adapted to all sorts of
    problems, domains, uses...
                                     For a computerized
                                     version, I use the fabulous
                                     notebook software
                                     OneNote.
Sources
●   Tony and Barry Buzan:
    The Mind Map Book
●   David N. Perkins:
    Outsmarting IQ
●   John Bransford / Barry Stein:
    The IDEAL Problem Solver

A New Problem Solving Method

  • 1.
    A New ProblemSolving Method Thomas Teepe February 19, 2011
  • 2.
    What is myaim? I present my favourite hands-on method of problem solving (… and of thinking in general)
  • 3.
    What are thebasic ideas? It's a combination of 2 things: This combination works for me much better than 1.notemaking each of its 2 components - using several clever tricks on their own. 2.tools for problem solving … with an emphasis on reflective thinking! 'Reflective ' sounded academic and boring. I thought again ;-) - reflection is central for solving tough problems.
  • 4.
    First: Second: Problem Solving Tools Notemaking
  • 5.
    Why Notemaking? Some famous notemakers: ● support concentration Leonardo da Vinci ● master complex thoughts Isaac Newton ● break down a problem into Charles Darwin smaller parts Ludwig van Beethoven ● collect ideas first Thomas Edison and examine them afterwards Pablo Picasso ● combine verbal and visual thinking Carl Friedrich Gauss ● see ideas from a distance Oscar Wilde ● document thoughts Alfred Hitchcock ● can be adapted in many ways
  • 6.
    Basics of the notemakingprocess 1 We use a two-column layout 1.left column for the main material 2.right column for For me, the 'reflection - reflection, column' is simple & effective support to guide - comments, my thoughts - questions - etc.
  • 7.
    Basics of the notemakingprocess 2 I use Some basic ideas come from mind mapping several elements in combination ● keywords ● hierarchical arrangement of ideas ● combining words and images ● colours (sometimes) I find tables very ● tables powerful - yet somewhat ● diagrams underrated and underused in mind mapping
  • 8.
    Some remarks onwriting materials Goal: ● get lots of content on one page Surprisingly relevant. ● … and stay legible This works well for me: Imho, superior to 0,5 mm ● mechanical pencil 0,3 mm HB ● a bound notebook blank pages, size A5 ● small handwriting even tiny
  • 9.
  • 10.
    Main start with Reflection Column the separation line Column
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
    add to doitems add checkmarks later
  • 16.
  • 17.
    Second: First was Notemaking Problem Solving Tools
  • 18.
    What is aproblem solving tool? naive but useful ● everything that may help defintion to solve a problem Examples ● brainstorm ● ask yourself questions ● ask a colleague ● search the internet ● sleep over it ● reflect: ● improve your ideas ● understand how you think
  • 19.
    How to organizeproblem solving tools? ● Step 1: Split the problem solving process into stages ● Step 2: For each stage, collect a number of useful tools ● Plus: Reflection tools that help at each stage
  • 20.
    Stages of problemsolving - a simple model: ● understand the problem ● define reasonable goals ● develop plans for the goals ● choose a plan ● carry out the plan ● reflect reflection is useful 1) in each of the other stages 2) for a final look back
  • 21.
    Here comes a smallcollection of tools for each stage
  • 22.
    Understand the problem ● start with a top-down analysis ● ask questions ● collect information about the problem ● internet search ● literature ● interview people ● draw a diagram
  • 23.
    Define reasonable goals ● What is the right thing to do? ● What would XY do? XY is a person I take as a role model in the given ● state goals clearly problem situation. ● describe SMART goals ● S - specific ● M - measurable ● A - attainable ● R - relevant ● T - time bound
  • 24.
    Develop plans forthese goals ● start with the goal and develop a plan backwards ● develop a plan top-down: start with a general plan and make it more specific ● ask repeatedly 'How can this be achieved?' ● exploit solutions from similar or analogue problems ● brainstorm for unusual ideas
  • 25.
    Choose a plan ● check the plans for obstacles, gaps... ● compare plans pairwise ● list the pros and cons ● trust your gut feeling
  • 26.
    Reflection In my experience, these ● So what? simple questions are What now? surprisingly powerful. ● collect shortcomings and criticism ● collect obstacles and barriers ● collect conflicts ● examine results
  • 27.
    I often useonly two simple sets of tools 1.one for the main column: I write these acronyms on PrAnGoPlExCo stands for top of the columns – each Problem Description time a useful reminder of Analysis good problem solving Goals practices. Plans Constantly adapting Execute plan these tools to my personal Control needs is paramount. 2.one for the reflection column: QOCS stands for Questions Obstacles Conflicts So what?!
  • 28.
    How to combinenotemaking and problem solving tools? Here is an example.
  • 29.
    Start with - separationline - tool acronym PrAnGoPlExCo - tool acronym QOCS
  • 30.
  • 31.
    start with tool'Pr' = Problem Description
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
    Advantages For me, themethod is... ● effective: notemaking + tools guide my thinking through problems ● efficient: no needless fuss - simple, quick, cheap and easily available ● flexible: can be adapted to all sorts of problems, domains, uses... For a computerized version, I use the fabulous notebook software OneNote.
  • 35.
    Sources ● Tony and Barry Buzan: The Mind Map Book ● David N. Perkins: Outsmarting IQ ● John Bransford / Barry Stein: The IDEAL Problem Solver