Google's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search Intent
1. Core updates from Google periodically change how its algorithms assess and rank websites and pages. This can impact rankings through shifts in user intent, site quality issues being caught up to, world events influencing queries, and overhauls to search like the E-A-T framework.
2. There are many possible user intents beyond just transactional, navigational and informational. Identifying intent shifts is important during core updates. Sites may need to optimize for new intents through different content types and sections.
3. Responding effectively to core updates requires analyzing "before and after" data to understand changes, identifying new intents or page types, and ensuring content matches appropriate intents across video, images, knowledge graphs and more.
Before The Timespresented evidence
of the paid links to JCPenney.com,
Google had just begun to roll out an
algorithm change that had a negative
effect on Penney’s search results.
- 2011 NYTimes article about JC Penney
19.
We are experiencingsome slowing of
our overall revenue growth which we
believe is due in part to changes
that Google made in its natural
search engine algorithms, to which
we are responding.
- overstock.com earnings report in 2015
How Google WantsYou To Think About It
Movie
Movie
Movie Movie
Movie
Movie
in 2017 in 2023
Best movies
29.
T h er e ' s n o t h i n g
wrong with pages
that may not be
performing as well
as they were before
a core update.
-
30.
In fact, there'snothing
in a core update that
targets specific pages
or sites.
Instead, the changes
are about improving
how our systems assess
content overall.
-
✴ Aggressive
advertising that
affectsusability &
performance
✴ Significant thin or
duplicate content
✴ Excessive low-quality
local landing pages
(doorway pages)
✴ Significant low-quality
content lacking E-E-A-T
✴ Deceptive affiliate links
✴ Being too “salesy” with
Your Money, Your Life
information
Examples of Systemic,
Site-wide Quality Issues
35.
We told themit was a bad idea
May 2020 Core Update
Client builT thousands
of “fake” local landing pages
A cautionary tale
from a former client
36.
(…and wait fornext
core update, or the
one after)
Prioritize fixing
these issues
Core Update Recovery Plan
Generic
SEO Responses “Weshould
build more
links to this
page”
“We should change
our title tag and
meta description”
“The #1 ranking
site has a better
Domain Authority
than us”
44.
Better, Data-Driven SEOResponses:
“There is a temporary surge in
demand due to recent press
around two new companies
called ‘Playground.’
It may subside over time.”
45.
Better, Data-Driven SEOResponses:
“‘Playground’ is not our top-
converting keyword. We should
analyze PPC data to identify the
highest converting related
terms to focus on.”
46.
Better, Data-Driven SEOResponses:
“We should shift our focus to
Google Shopping & Images,
where we see most conversions
for this keyword”
DURING THE STARTOF COVID
QUERY: MASKS
✴ Costume masks stopped
ranking on page 1
✴ The CDC, WHO, and FDA now
appear on page 1 (+ position 1)
✴ Wikipedia disappeared
49.
DURING THE STARTOF COVID
QUERY: FLOUR
✴ A bakery franchise lost top positions
✴ A site offering sourdough recipes now
ranks No.1
✴ Shift toward ecommerce for sites that
have flour in stock (Amazon & Target)
✴ Medical product
reviews& weight loss
supplements
✴ Fake authors, no real
E-E-A-T
✴ Pushed products in
medical content with
affiliate links and
discount codes
Other sites impacted by the
“Medic” core update:
56.
The rise ofmedical authorities
during the pandemic
SEOs always talkabout
“THE 3 SEARCH INTENTS”
1. Transactional 2. Navigational 3. Informational
64.
There are waymore than
3 intents in SEO.
Let’s be real.
65.
More accurate listof actual search intents
✴ Buying a product
✴ Looking for pictures
✴ Reading product reviews
✴ Finding local businesses &
activities
✴ Seeing recent news
✴ Fact checking
✴ Defining the word or phase
✴ Tutorials & troubleshooting
✴ Finding stock photos
✴ Recipes
✴ Medical symptoms
✴ Finding government
resources
✴ Seeing pictures
✴ Booking a trip
✴ Watching a video
✴ Hearing a song
✴ Translating a phrase
✴ Spell check
✴ How to
✴ Lyrics
✴ Adult videos/images
✴ Researching reputation
Google may determinethat
a keyword requires a new
“intent” & adjust rankings
during core updates
70.
✴ Zoom movedinto
position 2.
✴ Pages listing physical
rooms were replaced by
informational content.
✴ Wikipedia disappeared.
QUERY: “CONFERENCE ROOM”
Intent shifts at the start of COVID-19
If your siteis affected by a core update,
you might have to wait until the next
update rolls out, or the one after that,
to see a change in performance.
97.
Remember that intentshifts can be
inevitable and it’s not always easy - or
even possible - to use SEO to counteract
what Google chooses to rank.
98.
Optimize all thethings!
Provide content that meets all
possible intents to cover as much
ground as possible.