Creating A Checkout Process That Builds Trust

Buying is a risk. Especially online. That moment after someone places an order? That’s when they’re most likely to change their mind or start doubting their decision. Here’s what most brands do: • Send an order confirmation • Say “Thanks for your order!” • Then… nothing. Meanwhile, your customer is thinking things like: “Did I just waste my money?” “Is it actually going to show up?” “What if I need to return it?” That gap, between clicking buy and getting the product is a trust drop. But you can build that trust back. Here’s one simple way to do it: Day 0: Right after they order Make them feel good right away. • Use a clear, well branded order page • Show when it’ll arrive, how returns work, and what happens next • Optional but great: a short video from the founder saying “We’ve got it from here” Day 2: Reassure them Let them know they made a good choice. • Share real examples of how people use the product • Add a small tip that shows you get their needs Day 5: Teach, don’t sell This isn’t a time to push more products. • Help them get the most out of what they bought • If it’s clothing, share how to style it • If it’s a tool or gadget, give a quick guide to help them get started Day 12: Just checking in No hard sell. Just be helpful. • A simple message: “Any questions? Need help with anything?” Most people don’t stop buying because your product is bad. They stop because they feel ignored. Keep talking to them like a real person and they’ll stick around.

A lot of brands' checkout flow kind of comes off like a used car salesman. "Buy more!" "Don't leave!" "Last chance!" I get it. You've worked hard (and spent a lot) to get that customer there. But here's what we learned at Obvi this year - your checkout flow should act more like a trusted advisor than a pushy sales rep. Think about it: The customer is already interested. They've added something to cart. Now they're looking for validation, education, and maybe a little reward for taking the plunge. At this moment, you have 2 paths: - You can hammer them with aggressive upsells and urgency... - Or you can guide them toward the best possible experience with your brand. We figured out how to build path 2, and it changed everything. Here's how we think about it →  First, we educate. Our checkout shows relevant reviews that speak to specific results and experiences. Not just "great product!" but real stories from our 250,000+ customers about their journey. Next, we validate.  Every product in-cart gets paired with our guarantee, FDA certification, and "Made in USA" badges. But we also explain WHY these matter for supplements. Trust isn't just about logos - it's about context. Then we reward smart choices.  Instead of just offering random bundles, we show volume discounts that actually make sense. "Get 3 months supply, save 20%" hits different when you've just read reviews from people talking about their 90-day transformations. The results have been eye-opening 👀 - Higher AOV (because people are choosing bundles that fit their goals) - Better retention (because they're starting with the right products) - Fewer support tickets (because we're answering key questions up front) But the biggest win? People are actually excited about spending more with us. The checkout isn't friction - it's part of their journey to better health. You CAN use scarcity and urgency and all that kind of stuff to up purchase intent. But you have to do it right. AfterSell by Rokt has been crucial for testing and optimizing all of this for us. Remember: Your checkout flow isn't just about moving product. It's about helping the customer buy the right stuff for them and building the foundation for a long-term relationship. Educate. Validate. Reward. Make it helpful, not pushy.  Guide, don't grind.

Building your checkout flow is like crafting a sales conversation. Every element either moves customers closer to purchase or creates friction that drives them away. Most DTC brands obsess over ad creative but underestimate checkout design. Here's the truth: A well-designed checkout can lift revenue more than your best-performing ad. 3 critical areas to master: 🥵 Cognitive Load → Every question, field, or decision point in checkout adds mental friction. Your job? Remove unnecessary thinking. If a customer has to calculate free shipping thresholds or wonder about the order’s arrival day, that’s friction. 👍 Trust Signals → First-time buyers need different reassurance than repeat customers. Your checkout should adapt. New customers might need reviews and press features. Loyal customers want their status acknowledged and rewarded. 💎 Value Perception → Shipping costs hit differently at various price points. A $7 shipping fee on a $30 order feels expensive. The same fee on a $100 order? Barely noticeable. The problem is even when brands know these principles, they struggle to implement and test them effectively. That's where smart checkout optimization comes in. At Obvi, we've been methodically testing these elements. Our latest focus is reducing cognitive load around free shipping thresholds (FSTs)... Using PrettyDamnQuick with Avi Moskowitz, we tested adding a simple note showing exactly how much more a user needed for free shipping. No complicated math for customers. No uncertainty about what the threshold is or how to reach it... The results after 25 days →  • +$0.78 more revenue per customer (meaning the messaging IS pushing people to add more to their cart) • Better conversion rates • Higher average order values across the board This nicely illustrates why checkout optimization matters. One small friction point removed = real revenue impact.