Email marketing and user acquisition challenges

With CAC rising is EMAIL the? UK’s Most Underrated Acquisition Channel? In the UK, email is often underestimated in terms of customer acquisition. Meanwhile, in the U.S., it's a top-performing channel, with 81% of businesses using for acquisition (v. 80% for retention), with an average ROI of $36 for every $1 spent (DMA) you can understand why. So why the disconnect in the UK? A big part of it comes down to GDPR & perceived limitations around high-quality data. But after sending billions of acquisition emails for some of the UK’s biggest brands, I can say with confidence: email works—when done right. Here are my top 10 tips for using email as a scalable acquisition tool & ensuring you qualify traffic: 1. 🚫 Don't buy or rent data to send emails yourself Sender reputation determines inbox placement. You could buy the best list, but if you haven't engaged with them before, you are unlikely to inbox. Only work with senders who mail their data. (nb. Delivery is everything to them, so they will ensure your offer drives engagement or they wouldn't send) 2. 🤝 Trust senders to know their audience Ask providers what’s historically performed well—designs, content, send times. Use their insight to maximise your campaign effectiveness. 3. 🧪 ROI rarely comes from a single send Create a structured testing programme. Experiment with subject lines, creative formats, audiences, timing. Think performance, not one-and-done. You wouldn't run a one hit wonder on meta - so don't do it on email. 4. 🔁 Use a multi-touchpoint approach Just like paid media or social, consumers need multiple exposures before they convert. Plan repeat sends to build familiarity and intent. 5. 🖼️ Tell your story, but make it scannable Email gives you space—use it! Combine visuals, GIFs, storytelling. But keep it easy to skim, with prominent CTAs. Guide the reader clearly. 6. 🙅♀️ Skip the “Hi [First Name]” In acquisition, personalisation by name isn’t effective. You haven’t earned a relationship yet—focus on value and relevance first. 7. ✨ Nail your above-the-fold content The top section drives most engagement. Make sure your primary USP shines here. Grab attention fast, and give users a reason to click. 8. 👁️ Think beyond opens—email is brand awareness Even unopened emails contribute. People read subject lines and from-names when deciding what to engage with. An email from “M&S – 50% Off Sale” makes an impact, even if it’s deleted. 9. 📊 Question low open rates Thanks to auto-image loading, open rates are often inflated. So if your open rates are low, it may point to real quality issues—look deeper. 10. 🚀 It can be a pure acquisition channel Email makes it easy to exclude existing customers. Clean deduplication ensures you're reaching only new potential buyers. Email isn’t just a retention tool—it’s a powerhouse for acquisition, brand visibility, and testing at scale. UK marketers who embrace its potential will unlock a competitive edge that many are still missing.

An ecommerce company recently approached my team to do an email audit as they were facing challenges with low open and click-through rates. After analyzing their email account, here are our main recommendations to revive their email marketing channel: 1. Strategic Email Segmentation: Currently, your emails lack personal relevance due to a one-size-fits-all approach. This is a crucial area to address. Action Plan: Implement segmentation based on purchase history, engagement levels, browsing behavior, and demographic information. 2. Personalized Content Creation: Generic content won't cut it. Your audience needs to feel that each email is crafted for them. Action Plan: Develop emails specifically tailored to the different segments. This includes curated product recommendations, personalized offers, and content that aligns with their interests. 3. Subject Line A/B Testing: Your current subject lines aren't doing their job. You need to be implementing ongoing A/B subject line tests, as this is low-hanging fruit to improve your open rates. Action Plan: Regularly test different subject line styles and formats to identify what resonates best with each segment. Keep track of the metrics to inform future campaigns. 4. Mobile Optimization: A significant portion of your audience reads emails on mobile devices. Neglecting this is causing a decrease in your email engagement rates. Action Plan: Ensure all emails are responsive and visually appealing on various screen sizes. Test your emails on multiple devices before sending them out. Additional Campaign Strategies We Recommend: - Launch a Monthly Newsletter: This should include new arrivals, style guides, and user-generated content. It’s an excellent way to keep your brand in the minds of your customers. - Seasonal Campaign Integration: Tailor your campaigns to align with holidays and seasons. This approach can significantly boost engagement and sales during key periods. - Re-Engagement Campaigns: Specifically target subscribers who haven't interacted with your brand recently. Offer them unique incentives to rekindle their interest. Next steps: 1. If you found this helpful, please leave a comment and let me know. 2. If you own/run/work at an Ecommerce company doing at least $1 million in annual revenue, message me so my team can audit your email channel to see if there's a good fit for working together.

I've audited 65 Klaviyo accounts in the last 6 months. All of them can improve this with their campaigns: Segmentation. Who you reach, and who you choose not to reach, will make or break your success marketing to email subscribers. Most accounts had varying degrees of these issues: ↳ "Oversegmenting" Narrowing recipients down to groups that are too small and actually not reaching users that may otherwise likely engage with a message. I've seen tens of thousands of users, and in some cases higher, in single accounts that had not been sent any message in the prior 6 months, but did have any prior engagement flags where I'd otherwise recommend not sending to them. ↳ Ignoring Key Exclusion Groups Soft bounced in the last 30 days, but still able to receive messaging? Or 3 times ever? That's a common segment we recommend excluding. But, most don't segment these users, or anyone at all in some cases. ↳ Enriching User Profiles with Zero Party Data, But Not Using It If you've been following me at all recently, you've probably seen my posts about success our clients have had with list growth and conversion by asking people about why they are shopping and using that in messages. We've seen a lot of instances of brands collecting information, but then not using it at all. ↳ Sending to Recent Purchasers Big one -- Only 1 or 2 of the accounts I've reviewed were excluding recent purchasers across most campaigns. The far majority, however, were not. Generally, there isn't much of a need to try to market a product to users that just purchased something within the last 7 days, for example, and still even have a package in transit. Include them on product launches or key sales if you have to. Break some email admin habits with the above and you'll make more money before changing anything else to your send cadence, design, content, flows, etc.

I've run hundreds of email account audits, and I always see the same mistakes. Here are the "5 Deadly Sins" that are killing your email performance – and how to fix them. MISTAKE #1: TOO MUCH EMAIL VOLUME When it comes to email marketing, engagement is far more important than list size. Sending too many emails can overwhelm your subscribers, leading to lower engagement rates, increased unsubscribes, and damage to your sender reputation. This turns into a “boy who cried wolf” scenario, where too much volume results in your messages getting ignored or sent to SPAM. THE FIX: Focus on quality over quantity. Prioritize sending valuable content at a steady cadence rather than hitting an arbitrary volume target. MISTAKE #2: NOT SEGMENTING YOUR AUDIENCE If you’re still sending “email blasts” in 2024, you’re gonna have a bad time. Sending the same email to your entire list without considering a subscriber’s unique needs or interests is a recipe for terrible engagements, sales, and unsubscribe rates. THE FIX: Segment your list based on demographics,interests, or behaviors. Send hyper-personalized content to maximize relevance and improve conversion rates. MISTAKE #3: WEAK OR MISLEADING SUBJECT LINES Using vague, spammy, or clickbaity subject lines is an absolute no-no. If your subject line is unclear, it’s not getting opened. If it makes a promise that your content doesn’t deliver on, your subscribers will lose trust, killing your future engagement metrics. THE FIX: Craft subject lines that are both clear and compelling. Set expectations for what’s inside and make sure the email content follows through on that claim. MISTAKE #4: IGNORING MOBILE OPTIMIZATION Current estimates suggest that around 60% of website visits take place on mobile devices. Similarly, studies have shown that around 40-60% of email opens happen on mobile. So, why do so many brands invest thousands in mobile optimization for their SITE, and almost nothing in optimizing their EMAILS? THE FIX: Use responsive email templates that adjust to any screen size, and always test how your emails look on mobile before sending. MISTAKE #5: FAILING TO ANALYZE PERFORMANCE For many brands, email marketing is an item on a to-do list that just needs checked off. If you’re not running a post-send analysis to determine what’s working and what’s not, you are absolutely leaving money on the table. THE FIX: Analyze your email marketing metrics on a monthly basis to understand what’s working and use that to drive further experimentation and optimization. I see these mistakes in every single account I audit – and it KILLS me. Get these low cost, high impact opportunities dialed in and you’ll dramatically improve your results.